|
When
something happens at work which is dismissive of you or excludes you, you
must either speak up or exit the situation, if you truly want to redirect
the flow of events and launch some real communication. You don't have to
be shrill or abrasive to speak up; you can simply be firm and clear. You
don't have to physically exit either your job or the building; you can
distance yourself to an extent it becomes clear you have exited the
situation and its dynamics.
A large communication gap
exists between men and women in the workplace and the higher a woman rises
in an organization, the greater the gap becomes. There is no question that
all of us--- men, women and the companies which employ us, and depend on
us for teamwork--- would be better off if we developed strategies and
techniques to close the gap.
Stereotyping is
generally the culprit and both men and women have some responsibility for
continuing the dynamics it produces. Men are acting on old scripts which
were developed early on and may have been purely social in nature.
Stereotyping and its
effects are somewhat like the iron fist in the velvet glove: you don't
fear it when you see it coming but it packs a wallop which is often a
knock out punch. When, in a fairly common scenario, a man at work sees you
as possessing the feminine traits of being nurturing and kind, rather than
assertive and displaying leadership capability, he is is unlikely to
consider you for promotion to a leadership role. It is wise to remember
that women are not at work to be someone's mother or girl friend, sister
or buddy. You are there to achieve success and a fulfilling career; you
should think and act like someone who deserves success and will be able to
handle difficult tasks with swiftness and confidence. When women buy into
a "mother-wife-sister" stereotype, they not only perpetuate a frustrating
disconnect in communication but assure their own career euthanasia. Let
someone else get his milk and oreos or perform his support work; you be
his equal; you collaborate on reports, develop new concepts, and be very
firm about getting your fair share of the credit.
|
 |
As a result of this
stereotyping, and acting out of old scripts, dysfunctional communication
is alarmingly common in the workplace. One of the most common
communication disconnects is men talking over women, not giving them a
chance to speak or completely ignoring them. In fact, in a variety of
ways, women at work are often ignored, excluded, patronized, insulted or
undermined.
Women unwittingly
acquiesce to their own professional shrinking act by playing out some of
the same old, self- destructive scripts. Men can enjoy a spirited debate,
argue in the morning and buy each other drinks or catch a ball game as
soon as they leave the office. But women, who are not quite as thick
skinned, at times, value harmony, as our mothers, no doubt, taught us we
should. When offended, dismissed or patronized, our first instinct may be
to let it go. Don't make an issue of it. Blend in, we might pass without
notice. And all will remain peaceful, and maybe they will like and accept
us after all. But the "good girl camouflage theory" has proved a failed
strategy time after time.
You should not be afraid to speak up.
You are not at a tea party, or entertaining your grandmother. Recognize
that you are in a business context and business is about problems and
particularly about solving them, fast and completely. A certain amount of
conflict, disagreement, sparring about issues, debating choices and
solutions is inevitable. It's a rough and tumble world out there. If you
equate speaking up with being unpleasant and unfeminine, and particularly
with some man not thinking you're the girl he'd like to invite to the
prom, then you are already on the down escalator, thinking you might
magically, somehow, be going up. |
"Judy B. Rosener's
research published in the Harvard Business Review identifies
male-female communication style differences. She found that women
"encourage participation, share power and information, enhance other
people's self worth, and get others excited about their work."
Women often appeal to "equity and fair play." Men are much more
aggressive and go for the jugular. Women have a tendency to preserve
harmony over making their meaning perfectly clear so they tend to
"hint". Hinting preserves not only harmony but deniability. If you hint
and someone doesn't like it, you can deny you meant it that way. If you
want to practice diplomacy.....which frequently becomes about as
cantankerous as you can get......go to the U.N.; if you want to advance
your career, create as clear cut an impression as you possibly can.
|
 |
When something
happens at work which is dismissive of you or excludes you, you must
either speak up or exit the situation, if you truly want to redirect the
flow of events and launch some real communication. You don't have to be
shrill or abrasive to speak up; you can simply be firm and clear. You
don't have to physically exit either your job or the building; you can
distance yourself to an extent it becomes clear you have exited the
situation and its dynamics.
As Kathleen Kelley
Reardon, Ph.D. points out in "They Don't Get It, Do
They?....Communication in the Workplace - Closing the Gap Between Women
and Men", "The truth is that a wide range of communication
strategies exists between demure and abrasive. Clinging to either end of
the range is a recipe for failure. Many women worry that assertive
behavior will upset men and lead to disfavor. What they have failed to
consider is that they aren't exactly in favor anyway. Letting others
label your behaviors, direct the course of your interactions and
exclude, interrupt, and devalue you is not better than upsetting a few
men now and then."
Often the problem
women have is fear. You can't be afraid to either excel, speak up, take
a swing at bat or redirect communication in a way that is more positive
for you.
When two or three
male colleagues on a committee with you get together and have a meeting
without you, then tell you "it's no big deal", or "you're just too
emotional", don't accept it. Don't accept that this breech of corporate
procedure is about you, or that your emotions have anything to do with
it. Don't say your feelings were hurt or delve into someone else's
psyche for the reasons which might justify his behavior. Just say "I'm
on the committee and I should have been there. Simple as that. Don't let
it happen again."
If one of your male
colleagues suggests you came on strong in a meeting, don't fall back to
a Scarlett O'Hara or Melanie response, neither coquettish or limpidly
demure. Just say something on the order of "Thank you. A situation this
important really called for it."
Or, in a more neutral
vein: "How interesting you thought so."
After all, nothing of
much importance can be happening or discussed where there is absolutely
no conflict. Have the courage to take a stand.
As Reardon says" It's
fear that allows dysfunctional patterns of communication to continue.
Once women recognize that they can redirect interactions harmful to
their careers, they become empowered to manage the perceptions of others
and their own self perceptions as well."
This is a lesson we
must all learn to succeed. Men and companies would do well to learn it
also.
l
|